Thursday, 7 April 2011

A Brief Analysis of Doctor Who Series 6 Title ''The Curse of the Black Spot''

They're the same, right?
After the first seven Series 6 episode titles were revealed, an extensive conversation took place in the comments yesterday in which I somehow confused Treasure Island, the classic Robert Louis Stevenson novel that I read and loved as a child, with Disney's Treasure Planet. Didn't Long John Silver always have a robotic exterior and gruff voice acting, or has Janet Fielding just been dressing up as a Cyberman again?

In any case, my failure highlighted a particular bout of confusion with the title of Episode 3, "the pirate one". Called "The Curse of the Black Spot" and rivaling "A Good Man Goes to War" in both length and ambiguity, the episode requires a bit of background information, which is probably provided in the story, to understand the meaning behind the title.

What is the black spot? Well, to answer that, let's turn to the most reliable source around, besides Julian Assange. Wikipedia reports:
The Black Spot is a fictional literary device invented by Robert Louis Stevenson for his novel Treasure Island. In the book, pirates are presented with a "black spot" to officially pronounce a verdict of guilt or judgment. It consists of a circular piece of paper or card, with one side blackened while the other side bears a message and placed in the hand of the accused. It was a source of much fear because it meant the pirate was to be deposed as leader, by force if necessary--or else killed outright.
Speculation would suggest that Hugh Bonneville's pirate captain has received a black spot and believes that the Siren is about to take his soul . . . or something. Bonneville's CV has listed him as "Avery", certainly attesting to his identity as John Avery, an alias of an infamous pirate who died in 1696: the year in which "Curse" takes place.

Avery's treasure featured heavily in the Classic Series story The Smugglers. After his real-life attack on a Mughal convoy ship, a £1000 reward established the first recorded manhunt—across the world, no less! His last recorded whereabouts were in 1696, when he left the Bermudan island New Providence to set sail for Ireland. It's believed he died on some tropical island, or perhaps at the glowing hand of an ethereal Siren.
"Curse" most likely airs May 7th.

7 comments :

Punk Johnny Cash said...

I do hope there is a smugglers connection in the episode. I hope it is mentioned at least. Of the missing episodes it is one I have a fondness to. It was one of the target novelizations I enjoyed the most. Maybe they'll announce Smugglers was found and the black spot is an episode made to hype the release on DVD.... I wish.

Joe Shelby said...

I hope so, too. I always like the subtle connections between Moff stories and the classic series, like the fact that Beast Below made reference to the very same solar flares of Ark in Space.

It makes the continuity just work better in ways that are comforting to the (30-year) vet like me while not being anything that would throw off the newbies.

D0ct0r11 said...

DWM confirms this will air on May 7th, and gives to-be-confirmed dates for the following episodes (the usual episode a week format).

Tom said...

I like a good pirate story. Hoping this turns out be a great episode.

RabidPuppyDesign said...

when i heard black spot i though Pirate of the Carribean.

Susie said...

Anyone else getting flashbacks to "The Resurrection Casket"? I wouldn't put it past Moffat to start drawing on the audio books as well as the classic stories.

10thPlanet said...

I just realized — this is the only brief "Brief Analysis" I've done so far.